A nonprofit sues the feds over plans to paint the Lincoln Memorial Reflecting Pool blue : NPR
NPR Topics: Politics — 2026-05-11 19:10:00 — www.npr.org
With a blue sky above the Lincoln Memorial, people walk along the reflection pool in Washington, D.C., on June 9, 2023.
Jose Luis Magana/AP
hide caption
toggle caption
Jose Luis Magana/AP
A nonprofit is suing the National Park Service, the Department of the Interior and Interior Secretary Doug Burgum over the decision to resurface the Lincoln Memorial Reflecting Pool at Washington D.C.’s National Mall, and to paint the pool’s basin blue. The suit was filed Monday in U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia by The Cultural Landscape Foundation (TCLF), an education and advocacy organization. In the suit, TCLF is asking a federal judge to halt the project, saying that the Trump administration failed to have the project reviewed federally, as is dictated by the National Historic Preservation Act.
President Trump revealed his plans for the pool do-over last month in “American flag blue,” saying that the project would take one week and $2 million, and that it would be completed in time for the 250th anniversary of the Declaration of Independence on July 4. A few days later on Truth Social, the president posted a fake image of himself and several of his administration officials in swimsuits, along with an unidentified woman in a gingham bikini, lounging in the water with the Washington National Monument at the rear. (Swimming in the reflecting pool is prohibited by federal law.)
In a YouTube video posted by the White House on April 23, Trump called the pool “filthy dirty” and said it “leaked like a sieve.” In that video, Trump said he was going to call three companies that he has worked with in the past – “all they do is swimming pools” – and say, “Give me a good price.” The New York Times reported last Friday that the contract for the reflecting pool’s resurfacing was awarded in a $6.9 million no-bid contract to a company called Atlantic Industrial Coatings, which previously has never held any federal contracts. An employee at the Atlantic Industrial Coatings confirmed in a telephone call on Monday that it has been contracted for this project, but referred all other questions to the Department of the Interior.
The Times reported on Monday that the final cost of the project could be upward of $13 million, per documents it says it has obtained. The Department of the Interior did not confirm the cost of the project, but wrote: “The contract price reflects the effort necessary to expedite the timeline of completing the leak prevention coating project—more people, more materials, more equipment and longer hours ahead of our 250th.” In an unsigned statement emailed to NPR Monday afternoon, the Interior Department wrote: “The National Park Service chose the best company to expedite the repair of the iconic Reflecting Pool ahead of our 250 celebrations. The choice of American Flag Blue will enhance the visitor experience by making the pool reflect the grand Lincoln Memorial and Washington Monument. NPS is also investing in a state-of-the-art ozone nanobubbler filtration system and will now have a dedicated crew who will maintain the grounds’ from wildlife. The Department is proud of the work being carried out by our Park Service to ensure this magical spot can be enjoyed for not only our 250th, but for many generations to come.” Critics of the project, including TCLF, don’t share that vision – and are taking particular umbrage at the color. “The reflecting pool should not be viewed in isolation; it is part of the larger ensemble of designed landscapes that comprise the National Mall,” Charles A. Birnbaum, the president and CEO of TCLF, said in a statement emailed to NPR Monday. “The design intent, to create a reflective surface that is subordinate, is fundamental to the solemn and hallowed visual and spatial connection between the Washington Monument and the Lincoln Memorial. A blue-tinted basin is more appropriate to a resort or theme park.” The National Park Service regularly cleans out algae, goose droppings and other detritus from the reflecting pool. The last major renovation of the reflecting pool, which included the installation of a new circulation and filtration system, took place during the Obama administration at a reported cost of $34 million.
Before founding TCLF in 2008, Birnbaum served for 15 years as the coordinator of the Historic Landscape Initiative for the National Park Service.
TCLF has another open lawsuit against the federal administration: it is one of eight cultural and architecture groups currently suing President Trump and the Kennedy Center board over the planned renovations of the complex, which are planned to start in July.
A nonprofit is suing the National Park Service, the Department of the Interior, and Interior Secretary Doug Burgum over the decision to resurface the Lincoln Memorial Reflecting Pool in Washington, D.C., and to paint the pool’s basin blue. The Cultural Landscape Foundation (TCLF) filed the suit in U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia, claiming that the Trump administration failed to have the project federally reviewed as required by the National Historic Preservation Act.
President Trump announced plans for the pool renovation last month, stating it would be completed in “American flag blue” within a week and at a cost of $2 million, aiming for the project to be finished by the 250th anniversary of the Declaration of Independence on July 4. Shortly after, he posted a digitally altered image on Truth Social showing himself and several administration officials in swimsuits, which is particularly notable as swimming in the reflecting pool is prohibited by federal law. In a video released by the White House, Trump described the pool as “filthy dirty” and claimed it “leaked like a sieve,” expressing his intent to contact companies he had previously worked with to get a good price for the renovation.
The New York Times reported that the resurfacing contract was awarded as a $6.9 million no-bid contract to Atlantic Industrial Coatings, a company with no prior federal contracts. The final cost of the project could exceed $13 million, according to documents obtained by the Times. The Department of the Interior has not confirmed this cost but stated that the contract price reflects the necessary efforts to expedite the project. Critics, including TCLF, have expressed strong opposition to the color choice, arguing that it detracts from the solemnity of the National Mall’s landscape.
How this sits against verifiable accuracy
The claims made by Trump regarding the renovation of the Lincoln Memorial Reflecting Pool suggest a quick and cost-effective solution to a longstanding issue. However, the lawsuit filed by TCLF raises questions about the legality of the process followed by the Trump administration, specifically regarding the lack of federal review mandated by the National Historic Preservation Act. For these claims to be well-supported, one would typically expect documentation confirming the project’s compliance with federal regulations, as well as transparency regarding the bidding process for the contract awarded to Atlantic Industrial Coatings.
The excerpt does not provide any outside verification of Trump’s statements about the pool’s condition or the timeline and cost of the renovation. Instead, it highlights the controversy surrounding the project and the opposition from TCLF, which argues that the proposed changes undermine the historical significance of the reflecting pool.
What the excerpt shows about verifiable lies
The excerpt does not explicitly identify any statements made by Trump as false or misleading. However, it does highlight the controversy surrounding the project, particularly the legal challenges posed by TCLF regarding the administration’s failure to follow proper review procedures. The claims about the pool being “filthy dirty” and “leaking like a sieve” are presented as Trump’s opinions, and there is no evidence within the excerpt to confirm or refute these assertions. Readers would need additional documentation or expert analysis to assess the accuracy of Trump’s statements about the pool’s condition.
Targets and tone
The excerpt does not show Trump singling out or insulting specific individuals or groups. Instead, it focuses on the legal and administrative aspects of the renovation project and the criticisms from TCLF regarding the proposed changes. Trump’s comments about the pool’s condition do not contain disparaging language directed at any identifiable targets. The tone remains factual and centered on the implications of the project rather than personal attacks.
In summary, this item underscores the ongoing legal disputes surrounding the renovation of the Lincoln Memorial Reflecting Pool, highlighting the potential missteps of the Trump administration in handling the project. While Trump’s statements about the pool’s condition are noted, the excerpt does not provide definitive evidence to classify them as false or misleading. The controversy over the project’s execution and its implications for the National Mall’s historical integrity remains a significant point of contention.